The Bourbon Culture
Critic · 1 ratings
Rye whiskeys: avg 7.5/10 · median 7.8/10 · range 2–10 · 133 rated
Product
A. Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey Monongahela Mash
A. OverholtSpiritsRye Whiskey
ShelfRead verdict
Sources split
Sources split on this one. The Bourbon Culture puts it in the top 59.5% of rye whiskey, Breaking Bourbon in the bottom 6.4%. 2.5/5 on Breaking Bourbon (1 community rating) against a category median of 3/5, across 109 rated; 7.5/10 on The Bourbon Culture (1 community rating) against a category median of 7.7/10, across 126 rated.
A. Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey is a 2024 release from Overholt (James B. Beam Distilling Co., Clermont, KY) that revives founder Abraham Overholt's original 1810 Pennsylvania "Monongahela Mash" recipe of 80% rye and 20% malted barley. Bottled at 47.5% ABV (95 proof) after roughly four years of aging, it offers notes of caramel, sandalwood, baked spice and light nuttiness, and is positioned as a heritage-driven, contemporary rye for sipping neat or in classic rye cocktails.
Ratings
Ratings by source
See every available score on its original scale, with context from the source.
Purchase options
Available offers
5 offers
Official state lists
Price by state
Control states post one official price per bottle (750 ml). These come from the published state price lists, so each number is the real shelf price statewide. As of September 7, 2026.
- IowaIowa ABD · item #25125$30.00
- PennsylvaniaPA PLCB · item #100025544$39.99
- VirginiaVirginia ABC · item #025125$39.99
Cross-state typical price: $39.99.
Price history
Price over time
Recently spotted