#1
Old Forester Straight Bourbon 1920
Best bourbon on this shelf
It carries one of the strongest crowd consensuses here, backed by hundreds of ratings, while staying reasonably priced for what you get.
Checking the latestLoading
Whiskey Shelf Read
26 products identified
August 9, 2026 at 8:32 PM
Shelf view
26 products · 59 bottles1 / 6
Products
Products on this shelf
Sort by
Rating source
#2×4
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Worth the extra pour
This cask-strength release is a sought-after limited bottling that critics rate highly, offering more intensity and complexity for shoppers ready to spend a bit more.
Ratings
Offers
#3
Wild Turkey Rare Breed
Solid pour without the splurge
It comes in below most of its bottled-in-bond and barrel-proof neighbors while still earning respectable marks from critics, making it an easy everyday choice.
Ratings
Offers
Ratings
Offers
Ratings
Finding ratings
Offers
Ratings
Finding ratings
Offers
Ratings
Finding ratings
Offers
Show 21 unidentified items
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found
Could not identify
No match found