Hornitos Reposado vs 1800 Reposado: Which Reposado Wins the Margarita Shelf?

Both bottles land in the high 60s on Tequila Matchmaker's 100-point scale, well under the tequila category's median of 83. That's not a rounding error: it puts these two solidly in mixing-tequila territory rather than sipping-neat territory. Hornitos comes out slightly ahead on both the crowd score (70 vs. 69) and the critic score (62 vs. 61), a small but consistent gap across nearly 1,800 combined ratings.