The Fat Rum Pirate
Critic
Rums: avg 3.5/5 · median 4/5 · range 0.5–5 · 949 rated
Decanting the dataLoading
Product
Real McCoy 5YR
SpiritsRum
ShelfRead verdict
Middle of the pack
Right down the middle. Reviews and price both sit mid-pack. RumX drinkers give it 7.1/10 across 60 ratings, right in line with the typical rum (730 rated). The Fat Rum Pirate gives it 4/5, right in line with the typical rum (921 rated).
Compare ratings and available offers for Real McCoy 5YR, a rum found by ShelfRead.
Ratings
Ratings by source
See every available score on its original scale, with context from the source.
Purchase options
Available offers
10 offers
Official state lists
Price by state
Control states post one official price per bottle (750 ml). These come from the published state price lists, so each number is the real shelf price statewide. As of August 2, 2026.
Cross-state typical price: $26.09.
Price history
Price over time
Recently spotted
