PA PLCB
Pennsylvania Rum Prices
Prices as of September 7, 2026, from the PA PLCB published price list.
Every bottle on this page costs the same at all of the roughly 600 state stores in Pennsylvania. The price you see here is the price on the shelf, statewide. This page tracks the 121 rum bottles on the list.
Rated against their own category
The best value bottles in Pennsylvania Rum
These bottles score in the top of their category with specialist reviewers while costing less than most of it. Scores stay attached to their original sources.
Standing in front of the shelf in Pennsylvania?
Take one photo. ShelfRead identifies every bottle in the picture and shows you what each one costs and how it rates, side by side.
Take a shelf photo
Free, no signup
The full list
Every price in the list (121)
Bottles with specialist or community ratings come first, then the rest of the list alphabetically.
| Bottle | Size | State price | Change | Tier | Ratings | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Admiral Nelson's Cherry Spiced RumRum · #000003916 | 1750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 7.3/10The Fat Rum Pirate 0.5/5 | Mixed Reviews |
| Admiral Nelson's CoconutRum · #000003375 | 750 ml | $10.99 | unchanged | Well | RumX 6/10 | Budget Basic |
| Allegheny Distilling Maggie's Farm Spiced RumRum · #000036477 | 750 ml | $32.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7/10 | Middle of the Pack |
| Allegheny Distilling Maggie's Farm White RumRum · #000034235 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 7.4/10 | Middle of the Pack |
| American Distilling Co Conciere Silver RumRum · #000098014 | 1000 ml | $10.39 | new | Well | RumX 3.5/10 | Budget Basic |
| Appleton Estate Rare Blend 12 YearRum · #000032609 | 750 ml | $41.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7/10The Fat Rum Pirate 3.5/5 | Overpriced |
| Appleton Estate Signature BlendRum · #000004529 | 750 ml | $22.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5RumX 6.9/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi Coconut RumRum · #000005294 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 5/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi Dragon BerryRum · #000004108 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 4/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi Gold RumRum · #000005417 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 2/5RumX 5/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi Limon Rum (plastic)Rum · #000007676 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 4.3/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi Pineapple RumRum · #000006296 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 4.8/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi RaspberryRum · #000001313 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 3.1/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bacardi Superior RumRum · #000007970 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 2/5RumX 3.9/10 | Budget Basic |
| Bluebird Distilling Dark RumRum · #000098226 | 750 ml | $36.39 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 5/10 | Limited Reviews |
| Brugal Anejo Superior RumRum · #000004640 | 750 ml | $24.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 2/5RumX 6.1/10 | Below Par |
| Brugal Doble Reserva RumRum · #100053846 | 700 ml | $31.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7.7/10 | Worth It |
| Brugal Extra ViejoRum · #000096553 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 6.2/10 | Limited Reviews |
| Bumbu The Original RumRum · #000083161 | 750 ml | $36.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 0.5/5RumX 7/10 | Mixed Reviews |
| Bumbu XORum · #000085902 | 750 ml | $39.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 1.5/5RumX 7/10 | Skip |
| Calico Jack Spiced RumRum · #000005792 | 750 ml | $9.99 | new | Well | RumX 6/10 | Budget Basic |
| Calypso Silver RumRum · #100053967 | 750 ml | $7.99 | unchanged | Well | RumX 2/10 | Budget Basic |
| Captain Morgan Original Spiced RumRum · #000008865 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 0.8/5RumX 5/10 | Budget Basic |
| Cruzan Black CherryRum · #000009069 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | RumX 3/10 | Budget Basic |
| Cruzan Light RumRum · #000008385 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | RumX 6.2/10 | Budget Basic |
| Cruzan Peach RumRum · #100050039 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | RumX 4.8/10 | Budget Basic |
| Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva RumRum · #000077560 | 750 ml | $41.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7/10The Fat Rum Pirate 2.5/5 | Skip |
| Don Q 151Rum · #000098035 | 750 ml | $19.79 | unchanged | Call | RumX 7/10 | Middle of the Pack |
| Don Q Oak Barrel Spiced RumRum · #100050083 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 4.5/5RumX 7/10 | Mixed Reviews |
| Dos Maderas PX 5 Plus 5 RumRum · #000031681 | 750 ml | $41.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 1.5/5RumX 7.4/10 | Mixed Reviews |
| El Dorado Cask Aged 3 Years Demerara RumRum · #100066402 | 750 ml | $19.99 | new | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5 | Limited Reviews |
| English Harbour Rum 5 Year OldRum · #100053950 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 2/5RumX 7/10 | Below Par |
| Foursquare 2010 Single Blended Rum Exceptional Cask Selection Mark XXI 12 Year OldRum · #000088420 | 750 ml | $104.99 | unchanged | Ultra Premium | RumX 8.5/10 | Priced for Quality |
| Foursquare Sovereignty Rum Exceptional Cask Selection Mark XIX 14 Year OldRum · #000086861 | 750 ml | $129.99 | unchanged | Ultra Premium | RumX 8.6/10 | Priced for Quality |
| Goslings Black Seal Black RumRum · #000006913 | 750 ml | $21.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 6/10The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5 | Budget Basic |
| Gosling's Family Reserve Old RumRum · #000074270 | 750 ml | $69.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5RumX 7.5/10 | Mixed Reviews |
| Hamilton Demerara Overproof 151 RumRum · #100053076 | 750 ml | $34.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7.7/10 | Worth It |
| Hamilton Jamaican Pot Still Black RumRum · #100062581 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 7.7/10 | Worth It |
| Kirk And Sweeney Reserva RumRum · #000007655 | 750 ml | $38.49 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 6.8/10 | Below Par |
| Kraken Black Spiced RumRum · #000009825 | 750 ml | $21.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 5/10The Fat Rum Pirate 1/5 | Below Par |
| Leblon CachacaRum · #000009322 | 750 ml | $31.19 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Whiskyfun 2.5/5 | Unrated |
| Maggie's Farm 50 50 Pineapple RumRum · #000098445 | 750 ml | $36.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 6/10 | Limited Reviews |
| Malibu PineappleRum · #000009120 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 4/10 | Budget Basic |
| Mount Gay Black Barrel RumRum · #000007767 | 750 ml | $39.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 4/5RumX 7/10 | Overpriced |
| Mount Gay Eclipse RumRum · #000007868 | 750 ml | $22.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 1.8/5RumX 6.5/10 | Below Par |
| Mount Gay Extra Old Triple Cask Blend RumRum · #100038516 | 750 ml | $69.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 4/5RumX 7.8/10 | Mixed Reviews |
| Palm Republic Aged RumRum · #100063599 | 750 ml | $44.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 6.3/10 | Limited Reviews |
| Papa's Pilar Blonde RumRum · #100038589 | 750 ml | $34.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7/10 | Middle of the Pack |
| Papa's Pilar Dark RumRum · #100038590 | 750 ml | $44.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7.3/10The Fat Rum Pirate 1.5/5 | Mixed Reviews |
| Planteray XO 20th Anniversary RumRum · #100034989 | 750 ml | $58.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 8/10 | Priced for Quality |
| Probitas White RumRum · #000097411 | 750 ml | $27.74 | unchanged | Call | RumX 8/10 | Worth It |
| Pusser's British Navy RumRum · #000098108 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 7/10The Fat Rum Pirate 5/5 | Mixed Reviews |
| Rhum Barbancourt 5 Star Reserve SpecialeRum · #000030594 | 750 ml | $30.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 5/5RumX 7/10 | Mixed Reviews |
| Ron Barcelo Gran AnejoRum · #100038800 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | RumX 6.4/10 | Limited Reviews |
| Ron Barcelo Imperial RumRum · #100050706 | 750 ml | $33.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 2.5/5RumX 7/10 | Below Par |
| Ron Del Barrilito 3 Star RumRum · #100050892 | 750 ml | $39.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5RumX 7/10 | Skip |
| Ron Zacapa Centenario Rum 23 Year OldRum · #000008147 | 750 ml | $49.89 | unchanged | Top Shelf | The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5RumX 7.2/10 | Overpriced |
| Sailor Jerry Spiced RumRum · #000009091 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 3/5RumX 6/10 | Budget Basic |
| Santa Teresa 1796 Solera RumRum · #100068179 | 750 ml | $39.99 | new | Top Shelf | RumX 7.4/10The Fat Rum Pirate 4/5 | Overpriced |
| Wray & Nephew White Overproof RumRum · #000008680 | 750 ml | $23.99 | unchanged | Call | The Fat Rum Pirate 4/5RumX 7.5/10 | Middle of the Pack |
| Zaya Gran Reserva RumRum · #000007612 | 750 ml | $31.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | RumX 7.5/10 | Middle of the Pack |
| 3 Sisters Aged RumRum · #100037673 | 750 ml | $39.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| 3 Sisters Rum Banana RumRum · #100056566 | 750 ml | $22.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| 3 Sisters Rum Peach RumRum · #100056565 | 750 ml | $22.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| 3 Sisters White RumRum · #100037626 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Appalachian Craft Spirits Island Style RumRum · #000098947 | 750 ml | $24.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Bacardi Rum Reserva 8 Year OldRum · #000004691 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Banker's Club RumRum · #000004176 | 1750 ml | $13.99 | new | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Barcelo Imperial Rare Blends Maple CaskRum · #100067544 | 750 ml | $64.99 | new | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Big Spring Spirits Spiced RumRum · #000001005 | 750 ml | $32.19 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Bluebird Distilling Sugarcane RumRum · #000001321 | 750 ml | $31.19 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Bones Distillery Hot Cinnamon RumRum · #100056579 | 750 ml | $34.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Bones Distillery Moose Pie RumRum · #100056593 | 750 ml | $39.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Boyd and Blair Silver RumRum · #100029412 | 750 ml | $22.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Brinley Shipwreck Vanilla RumRum · #000006511 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Calico Jack Silver RumRum · #000006158 | 1000 ml | $9.49 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Captain Morgan Cherry Vanilla Spiced RumRum · #000097796 | 750 ml | $17.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Cask 520 Toffee RumRum · #100065232 | 750 ml | $38.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Cruzan BananaRum · #100050030 | 750 ml | $11.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Cruzan Blueberry LemonadeRum · #000001516 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Cruzan Coconut RumRum · #000004363 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Cruzan Mango RumRum · #100026245 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Cutwater Bali Hai Tiki Holiday SpiritRum · #000097336 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Devil's Reef Cinnamon Spiced RumRum · #100053406 | 750 ml | $31.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Don Q Cristal White RumRum · #000003517 | 750 ml | $17.69 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Don Q NaranjaRum · #100025236 | 750 ml | $17.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Five Saints Humane No 1 Maple Bourbon Butter Pecan RumRum · #000098038 | 750 ml | $36.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Hamilton Navy Strength RumRum · #100062580 | 750 ml | $32.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Hidden Harbor White RumRum · #000098442 | 750 ml | $36.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Hidden Still Spiced RumRum · #000049242 | 750 ml | $22.89 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Holy Water Distillery KLYR RumRum · #000097578 | 750 ml | $21.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Jackazz Distilling Vanilla RumRum · #100056588 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Jacquin's Gold RumRum · #000004306 | 1750 ml | $17.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Jacquin's White RumRum · #000004443 | 750 ml | $9.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Maggie's Farm 50 50 Dark RumRum · #000001511 | 750 ml | $36.39 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Malibu MangoRum · #000009118 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Midstate Distillery RumRum · #000098010 | 750 ml | $18.69 | new | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Myers's Dark RumRum · #000004290 | 750 ml | $18.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Novo Fogo Passion Fruit CachacaRum · #100052941 | 750 ml | $29.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Old Republic Distillery Gates House RumRum · #000098235 | 750 ml | $37.39 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Old Republic Distillery Plough Tavern Dark RumRum · #000098236 | 750 ml | $44.69 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Ozama Ron Dominicano Anejo RumRum · #100054382 | 700 ml | $25.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Palm Republic Silver RumRum · #100064707 | 750 ml | $34.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Parrot Bay Passion FruitRum · #000008837 | 750 ml | $13.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Pennsylvania Distilling Frontier Explorer's Gold RumRum · #000097841 | 750 ml | $31.19 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Planteray Barbados Rum 5 Year OldRum · #100034991 | 750 ml | $28.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Recipe 21 Spiced RumRum · #000002131 | 750 ml | $23.99 | new | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Red Brick Craft Distillery River Wards Aged RumRum · #100031477 | 750 ml | $45.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Ronrico Silver RumRum · #000006629 | 1750 ml | $18.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Saltwater Woody Grilled Pineapple RumRum · #100050130 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Siege of Wolves Barrel Aged Spiced RumRum · #100036040 | 750 ml | $31.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Siesta Key Toasted Coconut RumRum · #100038187 | 750 ml | $27.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Single Prop RumRum · #000001328 | 750 ml | $20.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Single Prop Spiced RumRum · #100044527 | 750 ml | $23.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Smith and Cross RumRum · #000030566 | 750 ml | $34.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Tenango RumRum · #100023813 | 750 ml | $44.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| The Kraken Gold Spiced RumRum · #100050426 | 750 ml | $19.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Tom's NecroNomNom Spiced RumRum · #100027694 | 750 ml | $44.99 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Trader Vic's 151 Proof RumRum · #100052933 | 750 ml | $16.99 | unchanged | Call | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Trader Vic's Coconut RumRum · #100034183 | 1000 ml | $9.99 | unchanged | Well | Not rated yet | Unrated |
| Wigle Landlocked Spiced RumRum · #000034244 | 750 ml | $31.19 | unchanged | Top Shelf | Not rated yet | Unrated |